The film writer Will Tracy has a hazy memory of what happens in Save the Green Planet!. It's a little surprising, considering he penned the script for the director’s latest reimagining of the original 2003 film. Rather than analyzing the original script for ideas, the screenwriter behind The Menu watched the film a single time, jotted down some thoughts, and started the process.
“I watched the original once,” Tracy states. “My memory was foggy on the film all that well. I didn't want to feel like I had to be slavishly following or remaking or paying tribute to another filmmaker's work. The most respectful approach to both films was to have them exist independently.”
While the premise of a emotionally troubled man (the actor in Bugonia) who kidnaps a pharmaceutical executive he’s certain is an alien in disguise is pretty much the same in both films, the variations are considerable. Firstly, Tracy rewrote the lead role, originally male in Jang Joon-hwan’s first version, as a female character. (The director cast his frequent collaborator Emma Stone in the role.) The endings differ slightly as well, in the way they tackle their central question: Is this person an extraterrestrial or not?
Tracy feels that resolution is somewhat not the main focus.
“I never was really focused on the surprise element,” he says. “I didn't want the film to just be a toy that performs one surprise, and then after the reveal, it's like: Alright, so what's next?”
Nevertheless, he has a lot to say on the topic. The interview with the writer covered Bugonia’s finale and what it all means, along with the methods he and the director worked together to execute those surprises.
Warning: Complete details ahead for the ending of Bugonia.
So is Emma Stone an alien or not?
Short answer: Absolutely.
Similar to in Save the Green Planet, the conclusion of Bugonia reveals that the CEO, a pharmaceutical executive named Michelle Fuller, is actually alien royalty in disguise. Once she manipulates her kidnapper the unstable man (Plemons) into ending his own life using her teleportation technology, Fuller beams back up to her Andromedon spaceship.
The reality that this comes as a surprise is a proof to Stone’s acting skills. During the two-hour movie, she maintains suspense through a complex portrayal that may take multiple viewings to fully understand.
“Emma frequently discussed how it was the initial instance she had to act where she felt she had to be aware of people watching the movie a second time. How those rewatching are going to perceive,” the writer explains. "She knew the upon a repeat viewing a person watches this movie, They know that I know that I'm… understand?”
He pauses, before continuing, “So she had to be aware of that in her acting.”
Designing the Andromedons and their spaceship
After Stone’s character ultimately shows her real identity, we get a quick look of her spaceship and fellow aliens before the film ends. Their ship has a distinct appearance, which the writer reveals was meant to look like a marine animal while avoiding high-tech visuals.
“[The director] was really fascinated by almost like a jellyfish-type design for the vessel, something quite organic,” he says.
The goal was for them to seem oddly somewhat tribal or primitive.
The aliens' attire is just as interesting as their ship: bulbous dress-like garments made from thick, woven cords. Once more, the goal was to go against conventional science fiction.
“Regarding the attire, rather than being advanced, they [were meant to|aimed to] feel strangely somewhat tribal or primitive, and yet also quite ornate and not primitive, because it's such an intricate and elegant creation on those strange knit costumes,” Tracy states. He adds that Lanthimos “thought of it as being a extremely old society. He wasn't into the notion of any element being smooth and metallic, or some ultra-modern cosmic vision.”
The end of the world (or only humankind)
Perhaps the biggest difference between the new film and the original is that in the original Korean movie, the extraterrestrials respond to their ruler's abduction and abuse by blowing up planet Earth. Bugonia adopts a slightly subtler method, with its beings choosing to eliminate all human life, while keeping the planet and its remaining creatures unharmed.
“My intention to do in the screenplay was a depiction of the planet post-human existence,” the writer explains.
In the movie’s final moments, we see a sequence of scenes of existence across the planet. Every person are deceased where they were located just before, but the Earth continues. How viewers, are meant to interpret these events is up for debate. Is the ending of Bugonia optimistic or pessimistic? Is humanity doomed or deserving of rescue? Is the planet be improved without us?
Tracy isn’t willing to provide a definitive answer in any direction.
“Some people find it to be a very bleak conclusion, or a sad ending, a hopeless ending,” he states. “Other people view it as being a strangely optimistic or positive conclusion. In my opinion there's different ways to read it.”
The film is currently in limited theatrical release now, with a wide release on Oct. 31.